The Pioneer Woman’s Restaurant Style Salsa (and The Quest for Good At-Home Mexican)

What was left of The Pioneer Woman's Restaurant Style Salsa after one day. Dawn and I can put away some salsa.

Dawn and I are pressing on in our quest to create the perfect at-home Mexican food.  Our first great success was the adaptation of this near-perfect burrito sauce from a Cooks.com recipe.  We both almost always order a bean burrito, so this was a big success.  We’re still working on perfecting the filling, though.  I know at restaurants they just shove some refried beans in there and call it a day, but we’re shooting for something a little more… something, but we’re not sure what that is (which is probably the problem).  The first time we made these burritos it was because we had lot of leftover bean and veggie mix that we were sick of rolling up in tortillas but couldn’t bring ourselves to throw out.  That filling was good, but no one really remembers what was in it other than various vegetables and beans in various quantities.  The second time I made them I just used a combination of a few different types of beans.  This was okay, but on the whole pretty bland because the filling was just beans, and I didn’t even have time to mash and refry them (whatever that means).  The most recent time we made the burritos, we made a filling of a few different kinds of beans, diced carrot and mushroom, a little salsa, various spices, and brown rice.  This was good, but it seemed to be still missing something–though I have no idea what.  But, really, that’s not what this post is about.

This post is about salsa.  More than burritos or Mexican rice, Dawn and I are pretty crazy about salsa.  When I say I’m in the mood for Mexican food, what I usually mean is I’m in the mood to eat about 5 lbs of chips and salsa and then complain that I’m about to be sick the whole way home.  There are plenty of foods that I love and can’t get enough of, but my love of chips and salsa is past that point.  Sometimes I think I actually need it to survive.  Having said that, I’ll say now that it’s nice to know that if we’re ever snowed in for weeks on end (like that will happen anytime soon in southwest Louisiana), my existence will be sustained as long as I’m able to make this slight adaptation of The Pioneer Woman’s Restaurant Style Salsa recipe.  We added a little more sugar, and left the cilantro out entirely (yuck!).  This is, by far, the best at-home salsa we’ve had.  Now I’m free to focus my efforts on perfecting that burrito filling (suggestions?) and finding a decent Mexican rice recipe.

To make this, you’ll need:

  • 1 28 oz can whole tomatoes, with juice
  • 2 10 oz cans diced tomatoes with green chiles
  • ¼ C chopped onion
  • 1 clove garlic, minced
  • 1 jalapeno, diced
  • 1 t sugar
  • ¼ t salt
  • ¼ t ground cumin
  • juice of one small lime
  • Combine all ingredients in a blender or food processor. Pulse 10 to 15 times, testing once or twice with a tortilla chip for consistency and seasoning.  Adjust as needed enjoy!

    Related Posts:

    Bangin’ Burrito Sauce Recipe

    We love Mexican food around here, and I don’t mean we eat a lot of Taco Bell.  I mean Dawn and I crave salsa like some people crave sugar or nicotine (we’ve been known to drink it or eat it with a spoon), and when there’s a good, cheap Mexican restaurant around I have no problem with eating there multiple times a week.  We’ve stumbled upon some pretty great restaurants in our new town: an all night diner with really cheap gravy and biscuits, a bar/restaurant with the most amazing homemade salad dressings and a veggie burger that will knock your socks off, and some pretty decent sushi and pizza places.  All the Mexican places we’ve eaten, however, have tasted a little too much like chain restaurants to me.  So, we’ve resorted to trying our hand at cooking Mexican at home.  Up until now, the results had been decent enough, but nothing close to Mexican restaurant quality and certainly nothing worth blogging about.  Nachos are easy enough, and anyone can make a quesadilla, but burrito sauce and salsa have been the two most difficult things to recreate at home.

    homemade burritos with Mexican rice

    Now we can cross burritos off that list!  Kirby made this bean mix the other night that we’ve been rolling up in tortillas and eating with salsa for the last few days.  Those were good, but we were ready for something new.  We adapted this burrito sauce recipe from Cooks.com, and we’re so pleased with results!  It’s probably not the healthiest thing we could eat, but it makes enough for at least six burritos and the filling is healthy enough that I don’t feel too bad about it.  This is definitely something we’ll be making again sooner than later.

    To make this sauce, you’ll need:

    • 1 stick unsalted butter
    • 1 not-chicken bouillon cube
    • 1 lg. diced onion
    • 1 jalapeño peppers
    • 2 T flour
    • 1 qt. jar tomatoes or lg. can crushed tomatoes
    • 2 bay leaves
    • 1/2 t cumin
    • 1/4 t crushed red pepper
    • 1 t unbleached sugar
    • a couple of grinds of black pepper

    Melt the butter in a large skillet (we almost exclusively use cast iron) and dissolve boullion cube and be prepared for one of the most delicious smells of your life. Saute the onions, jalapeno, and garlic in the butter mixture until they’re translucent and starting to get crispy.  Add the flour and stir to thicken.  Add the tomatoes and tomato juice, crushing any whole tomatoes with your spatula.  Add the bay leaves, cumin, red pepper, sugar, and pepper and allow the mixture to simmer for at least fifteen minutes (or until the flavors have melded).  While the mixture is simmering, fill and roll your burritos and line them up in a baking dish.  Once the burrito sauce has finished cooking, ladle the mixture over the burritos and bake for about 20 minutes at 350º.  Serve with Mexican rice or chips and salsa.

    You can fill your burritos with whatever you like, but we used a mixture of jalapeños,  black beans, pinto beans, kidney beans, carrots, jicama, red bell pepper, onions, garlic, canned tomatoes, grilled corn, and coriander, cumin, and chili powder.  We are planning on making these again soon and filling them with plain old refried beans.

    Related Posts: